|home | who we are | research | cancer info | study info | scientific resources | newsletter | donate | contact |FAQs|
For information on participating in a lab research study or clinical trial, click here.
Osteosarcoma is the most common type of primary bone cancer in dogs accounting for up to 85% of tumors that originate in the skeletal system. It is estimated that at least 6,000 new cases, and perhaps even more than 8,000, are diagnosed in dogs each year in the United States. Osteosarcomas are seen most often in the appendicular skeleton (long bones of the limbs), most often “near the knee” and “away from the elbow.” However, these tumors can also affect the axial skeleton (cranium, spinal column, ribs). Large and giant breed dogs are at higher risk for bone cancer, especially of the long bones. For example, it is estimated that the relative risk to develop this disease in giant breeds such as Scottish Deerhounds and Great Danes may be as much as 200-times higher than in small and toy breeds. Among dogs at high risk, we also include Rottweilers, Great Pyrenees, Greyhounds, Mastiffs, and others. The disease usually becomes evident during middle age (~7-10 yr), although bone cancer can affect dogs under 1 year of age. Factors that affect growth rate, such as diets that promote rapid growth in puppies, also appear to influence risk. The tumors are very aggressive and metastatic, so it is a fair assumption that at the time of diagnosis the disease will have already spread beyond the primary site. For this reason, the standard-of-care for bone cancer includes surgery to remove the primary tumor, followed by adjuvant chemotherapy to attack the cells that have left the site. In dogs, approximately 50% survive one year with standard-of-care, less than 30% survive 2 years, and less than 10% reach 3 years. These statistics are tempered when we consider that one year is approximately 10% of a canine lifetime; however, we feel that new therapies designed to exploit the genetic and biochemical abnormalities of the tumors will help us improve the outcome of dogs with this disease.
The following article was first published in 2 parts in Discoveries (Issue 32, Spring 2010). Discoveries is the official newsletter of the AKC Canine Health Foundation). Copyright for the artcile belongs the Animal Care and Cancer Research of the University of Minnesota. It can be distributed and reproduced for individual use and for non-profit purposes.
Bone Cancer in Dogs – What is the State of Practice and New Research?
In this article, I will briefly review the biology of bone cancer, how it is diagnosed, options for treatment, expected outcomes, and new information that will help us improve strategies for prevention, control, and treatment of primary osteosarcoma in dogs and children alike.
Osteosarcoma occurs in humans, dogs, and cats. In people, osteosarcoma is predominantly a pediatric disease with peak onset by ~15 years of age. This tumor is infrequent in adults, although the incidence after adolescence increases somewhat with age and a second smaller peak of incidence is noticed in adults after age 60. Primary osteosarcoma is a rare tumor, with fewer than 1,000 diagnoses per year. However, because of the demographics of the disease (i.e., the adolescent peak), osteosarcoma is considered an oncologic priority. Osteosarcoma is much more common in dogs than in people (~15 times), with an estimated ~10,000 new diagnoses each yearly mostly in large and giant breed dogs. Osteosarcoma is seen only rarely in cats.
Osteosarcoma accounts for approximately 85% of bone tumors in dogs. The median age at diagnosis is ~8 years, with a small peak of incidence in young animals (younger than 3 years). Yet, when the effect of body mass is taken into account, the overall risk for any dog to develop primary osteosarcoma is not magnified with increasing age. Dogs heavier than 90-lb account for almost 1/3 of cases, and most tumors in this group occur in the appendicular skeleton (limbs). Dogs under 30-lb account for less than 5% of cases, and in this group, most osteosarcoma occurs in the axial skeleton (bones outside the limbs). In cats, there is no association with size or breed and the frequency of axial tumors is about the same as appendicular tumors.
In dogs, appendicular osteosarcoma occurs in the metaphysis (at the site of the growth plates), “near the knee and away from the elbow.” Occasionally, osteosarcoma will occur in the digits. Axial osteosarcoma can occur in any bone outside the limbs (skull, ribs, spine). Extraskeletal tumors are rare; in humans they occur almost exclusively in adults and most often in the skin. In dogs they can arise anywhere, including visceral organs (liver, spleen, heart), eyes, etc.
Etiology and Risk Factors of Osteosarcoma
Environmental factors that increase risk for osteosarcoma include rapid growth (therefore “large breed” puppy food has reduced levels of available energy to increase the time needed for these dogs to achieve their full size and mass potential), gender (the risk for males is 20 - 50% greater), and metallic implants to fix fractures. Chronic trauma and microscopic fractures have been proposed as risk factors, but this is difficult to prove conclusively. There was a study from David Waters’ group at Purdue University (Cooley et al., 2002), where survey data provided by owners showed an increase in risk to develop osteosarcoma in dogs that were spayed or castrated at an early age. The relative risk estimated from this study was as high as 4-fold higher for dogs neutered before one year of age than for intact dogs. Glickman’s group published similar data in 1998 based on analysis of cases in the Veterinary Medical Database (Ru et al., 1998). These studies generated significant debate and concern among veterinarians and owners. Nevertheless, the results have not been reproduced consistently in other large population studies (for example, the study by Phillips et al on Scottish Deerhounds). While the results from Waters’ group may have increased some owners’ reluctance to neuter or spay dogs, the possible 3-fold increase in risk of osteosarcoma in females should be placed in context of the reduced risk of mammary cancer by spaying prior to the first estrus. Specifically, the probability to develop mammary cancer decreases from about 1 in 10 to about 1 in 100 (or less) when female dogs are spayed before their first estrus. In males, the possible 4-fold increase in risk of bone cancer should be placed in context of behavioral problems, such as territorial aggression, roaming, marking behavior, and physiological problems such as prostatic hyperplasia and testicular cancers that appear more commonly (or exclusively) in intact male dogs.
Natural History of Canine Osteosarcoma
Diagnosis of Canine Osteosarcoma
Nuclear scintigraphy is very sensitive, but not specific to identify lesions associated with osteosarcoma, as any region of osteoblastic (bone growth or remodeling) activity will be identified (i.e., arthritis). Nuclear scintigraphy is useful to determine the extent of primary tumor involvement. Fine needle aspiration cytology is commonly used as an adjunct to confirm a radiographic diagnosis. Fine needle aspiration cytology alone is generally not sufficient to make a definitive diagnosis, but the presence of “flag cells” with eosinophilic material, granular cells, and variable cell size and shape can support the diagnosis. Definitive diagnosis requires a biopsy, which can be obtained through an open incisional biopsy, a trephine biopsy, or a Jamshidi bone marrow biopsy needle. The diagnostic accuracy is almost 100% for open biopsies, ~95% for trephines, and >90% for Jamshidi needle biopsies. Biopsies should be obtained from center of lesion, and if a limb-sparing procedure is elected, the surgeon performing the surgery should perform the biopsy whenever possible.
The pathologist will define the cell type (osteoblastic, chondroblastic, fibroblastic, or mixed, as described above), the grade (degree of heterogeneity within the cell population, fraction of cells that is actively dividing, etc.), and verify the presence of tumor osteoid, which is diagnostic for osteosarcoma. Other confirmatory tests can include immunohistochemistry, staining for osteocalcin, osteonectin, and alkaline phosphatase (ALP).
Staging and Prognosis for Canine Osteosarcoma
In children, the site of primary disease is prognostic with tumors in the distal extremity carrying the best prognosis, tumors in the distal femur carrying intermediate prognosis, and tumors in the axial skeleton carrying the worst prognosis. In dogs, tumors of the mandible and scapula carry the best prognosis with a median survival of ~18 months, appendicular tumors have intermediate prognosis with a median survival of ~11 months, tumors of the spine and skull carry a worse prognosis with a median survival of ~6 months, and extraskeletal tumors carry the worst prognosis with a median survival of ~2 months.
Tumor size is prognostic (the larger the tumor, the worst the prognosis), as is age (younger dogs do worse). Serum ALP levels also are predictive. Dogs with pre-operative levels of ALP> 110 U/L carry a worse prognosis than dogs with ALP <110 U/L (levels may be variable depending on lab), and dogs that have elevated serum ALP 40 days after amputation are likely have the worst outcome among all groups of treated dogs.
Treatment of Canine Osteosarcoma
In very rare instances, dogs with osteosarcoma that receive palliative care may have prolonged (>1 year) survival, even in face of metastatic disease. Nevertheless, many well-controlled studies show that a clinical response for osteosarcoma is only achievable using the accepted standard of care. Osteosarcoma does not respond to other treatments, and anything other than standard of care should be considered palliative. Anecdotal benefits reported from herbal or “alternative” treatments, including Artemisin, have not been reproducible, and no alternative therapies have been shown to have efficacy or provide consistent clinical benefit in controlled trials.
Surgery is the mainstay for local control. In most cases, it provides immediate pain relief with high level of function. The only contraindication is poor structural soundness (not size). Case selection and an experienced surgeon (and recovery team) are important. Physical therapy and rehabilitation appear to improve quality of life and both patient and owner satisfaction. Complementary therapies like massage also may be beneficial. Complications are more frequent with limb sparing surgeries, where infection is the most common adverse event. Curiously, dogs that get infections at the surgical site and that respond well to antimicrobial therapy have better outcomes than dogs that do not get infections. This has been postulated to be secondary to activation of antitumor immune responses as a bystander effect of the response to the infection.
Radiation therapy provides local control and is palliative. The use of radiation therapy offers no added benefit to overall survival. Generally, there are no side effects and more than 70% of treated dogs show improvement, especially regarding pain. However, dogs that are not treated surgically remain at very high risk to develop pathologic fractures. An approach using Stereotactic RadioSurgery (STS) was recently adapted for use in dogs and is available at various institutions in the U.S. (e.g., University of Florida, Colorado State University, and others). It is too early to determine how success with this approach will compare to that seen with conventional surgery or limb-sparing surgery.
Metastasis is common, and almost inevitable. Treatment options include pulmonary metastasectomy. Metastasis treatment is only recommended if the primary tumor remains in complete remission and if there are only 1 or 2 nodules detectable in the lungs on three thoracic views. Results from bone scans should be negative. The median survival after pulmonary metastasectomy can be up to 6 months, but without procedure, survival is usually less than 2 months.
Other adjuvant therapies have been tested in controlled trials. Non-specific immunotherapy using an agent called L-muramyl-tripeptide-phosphatidylethanolamine (L-MTP-PE or 3-mifamurtide) as an add-on to amputation + cisplatin showed a median survival of 14 months with 40% of dogs surviving 2 years (Kurzman et al., 1995). This compound is being tested again as a possible addition to the current standard of care, and it recently was shown to improve survival for children with osteosarcoma when combined with standard of care therapy. No other therapies have shown any promise so far, although there are numerous ongoing clinical trials using compounds that activate the immune system (TNF, FasL) or targeted drugs (Rapamycin). An example of one such trial was recently published (Paoloni et al., 2009), and although improvement over the standard of care was marginal, it documents the infrastructure available to investigate new approaches for this disease.
The Future of Prevention, Diagnosis and Therapy
Gavin, K. et al. (2009). Paper presented at: Genes Dogs & Cancer: Fifth International Canine Cancer Conference (Orlando, FL, International Veterinary Information Services).
The author appreciates constructive post-publication comments from the Editors of the Alpenhorn to improve clarity of this article.
University of Minnesota College of Veterinary Medicine | University of Minnesota Cancer Center
© 2004-2010 Modiano Lab
Site Design by © Klein Buendel Inc.